74 Comments
User's avatar
Stone River Sea's avatar

i recently moved house and have been gifted with a whole clattering of jackdaws ! They are wonderful characters - thank you for helping me understand them more..

Expand full comment
rebecca hooper's avatar

Oh I'm so glad you have a clattering of jackdaw in your life! Thank you for your lovely comment.

Expand full comment
Mary Beth Rew Hicks's avatar

Congratulations on your publication, Rebecca. It really resonated with me, what you said about neurodivergence and curiosity about the inner lives of others. Beautiful essay, once again.

Expand full comment
rebecca hooper's avatar

thank you Mary Beth! It seems to me that many neurodivergent folk are intensely curious about the minds of others (despite some stereotypes to the contrary)

Expand full comment
Claire Polders's avatar

“It is a tonic, to feel so small; to feel like a part of something so much bigger than ourselves.” Absolutely. And it’s what I’m feeling now, traveling in the Galápagos. Life-changing.

Expand full comment
rebecca hooper's avatar

oh incredible, Claire! I would love to visit the Galápagos one day. I hope you are having an incredible time.

Expand full comment
Claire Polders's avatar

Thank you, and I am. (My posts are all about the journey there now.)

Expand full comment
Gill Moon Photography's avatar

A beautiful piece of writing Rebecca. I love Jackdaws, they nest in my chimney and chatter away on my roof and I get so much pleasure from watching them. Thank you for adding to my knowledge, it was good to learn more about these birds that always make me smile.

Expand full comment
rebecca hooper's avatar

Thank you! I'm so glad you enjoyed it and can love your jackdaws from fresh angles!

Expand full comment
Jan Elisabeth's avatar

What a wonderful way to begin a Sunday -- the attention to these creatures is inspiring.

Expand full comment
rebecca hooper's avatar

Thank you Jan, I'm so glad you enjoyed it!

Expand full comment
Anna Gaynes's avatar

Thank you for this. It's so amazing with how much patronage (and cruelty) we often treat nonhuman beings. 😥

Do you follow the discussion around interspecies communication? Speech buttons and tablets and the like to communicate with all kinds of animals. I love following the story of Parrot Kindergarden on Insta, they just recently published a study on that and they just now have a documentary film out. And I've been using speech buttons with my dog as well, it's really amazing.

Expand full comment
rebecca hooper's avatar

I don't know much about this but I am really interested! I've seen videos of a dog that's been trained with a button board and it's fascinating to watch this new method of interaction unfold. I'm a big fan of Irene Pepperburg's work on parrot-human communication (there's a great Moth podcast on her work!). How are the speech buttons going with your dog?

Expand full comment
rebecca hooper's avatar

*pepperberg, I should say!

Expand full comment
Anna Gaynes's avatar

https://parrotkindergarten.com/research/

This might be interesting. 😁

I've made very good experiences with the speech buttons. She was able to indicate when she wanted to go out, or play, or ask for spcific toys or ppl. And also just comment on things happening in our surroundings. It gives animals agency. I love it!

Expand full comment
Gen Sandalls's avatar

Thank you for a deeper look at the lives of jackdaws and the gorgeous prose, and poem.

Expand full comment
rebecca hooper's avatar

I'm so glad you enjoyed it, Gen!

Expand full comment
Holly Starley's avatar

What joy to be so small—and to be astonished by details like a jackdaw pair being subtly aware of their partner’s mood shifts and to understand the stunning wonder and importance of recognizing the intelligence of the creatures we share this planet with—what joy all this indeed.

As always, rebecca, quite grateful for your words.

Expand full comment
rebecca hooper's avatar

so grateful that you are here reading my words, thank you Holly!

Expand full comment
Idris - photography's avatar

There used to be a huge flock of jackdaws near to the school I studied in. They gathered in the trees in the evenings, and the sounds of the flock at dusk are a somewhat deeply ingrained memory. I always found their calls to be a little nostalgic, so when I think back to my highschool days, the jackdaws come to mind quite often along other memories.

Expand full comment
rebecca hooper's avatar

oh that's so lovely to read. I feel a similar nostalgia for jackdaws after spending these springs with them, and moving to a place that does not have many. I love the musicality and enthusiasm of their calls!

Expand full comment
Rebecca Cook's avatar

This is wonderful. I listened to it, instead of reading. What a marvelous reader you are. Being American, I'm a sucker for a British accent! I love knowing what you do, your research, and this gives me great pause--that there is more to things than meets the rapid, hurried eye. I used to play with chickens as a child. I played WITH them, I think. They knew who I was. And the rooster would attack. And attack. And attack. But the hens were every-friendly. Thank you for all this insight and beauty. Just lovely.

Expand full comment
rebecca hooper's avatar

oh thank you Rebecca, I'm so glad you enjoyed the audio! I'm sure those hens were enjoying your games just as much as you were! I feel we are able to tap into interspecies communication and shared actions better when we are younger. Perhaps in part because our minds are more open when we are young, and also we are more willing to just engage in play for play's sake!

Thank you so much for becoming a paid subscriber to between two seas, it is so appreciated! I hope you continue to enjoy it :)

Expand full comment
Hillel Brandes's avatar

Thank you for sharing some reflections from your research. I’ll have to check out you published papers. From one scientist to another, thanks!

Expand full comment
rebecca hooper's avatar

Thank you Hillel, I hope you enjoy!

Expand full comment
Dave Mead's avatar

Once again, astonishingly good writing that provokes so many thoughts and feelings. I don’t know how you do it but I’m very glad you do.

Expand full comment
rebecca hooper's avatar

this means a lot, thank you Dave!

Expand full comment
Alaina's avatar

I love the jackdaws that hang out in the willow tree at the back of my house. There are two huge willows there, but for some reason they have a preference and most sit in just one tree. They like to launch themselves off the top on windy days, fly round in a loop, and go back to do it again. ❤️

Expand full comment
rebecca hooper's avatar

oh I love that! corvids seem to be especially good at just having fun ;)

Expand full comment
India Flint's avatar

I have a memory of encountering birds (that I’ve remembered as jackdaws) on a high mountain pass on the slopes of the Säntis in October of 1983…and sitting down to watch them for an hour or so because they were so fascinating (and seemed equally curious about me)…but on reflection perhaps they were more likely alpine choughs, and my mind is playing tricks with me…

Expand full comment
rebecca hooper's avatar

either way, brilliant birds! Corvids are so wonderfully curious. I love that as we watch them, we too feel watched. Thank you for sharing this lovely memory :)

Expand full comment
Jenny Golding's avatar

I very much enjoyed this post, thank you.

Expand full comment
rebecca hooper's avatar

I'm so pleased, thank you Jenny!

Expand full comment
Kimberly Warner's avatar

I love that your scientific investigations help keep the beautiful mystery alive Rebecca. Attention and curiosity fostering more attention and curiosity.

Have you heard of the podcast Telepathy Tapes? While its focus is on telepathic communication between humans, (and is FASCINATING!), I found myself thinking that animals and plants may do this constantly, naturally. Consciousnesses unbound by physical form. How special to devote your skills to jackdaws! You observed chatters and preening, but how fun to imagine all the communication happening that we can’t even begin to detect.:)

Expand full comment
rebecca hooper's avatar

this is such a good point - there is SO much we do not know about animal communication that there are probably lots of super subtle behaviours/sounds/etc that we aren't even perceiving. This was something that came up in the peer review process - the reviewers were asking 'but what are the jackdaws picking up on to know their partner is stressed?' and our answer was we simply don't know! so many wonderful mysteries left to wonder at and unpick :)

Expand full comment